Claudette Konola
 
I am appalled by two things this morning: A post to this blog by my favorite Troll, and the results of a survey taken by School District 51.

Troll first. There is a member of the Tea Party who seems to believe that he is well informed on issues. I don’t know much about this individual, other than he is angry, doesn’t know how to string a coherent thought together into a sentence, is incapable of articulating a logical argument, and is misinformed about all manner of things. His post yesterday was about the new Western Colorado Congress of Mesa County website. He calls it a “victim” website. A website that posts the actual oil and gas regulations and all manner of news articles on topics involving human health is the opposite of a “victim” website—not that I’m sure what he means by “victim” website.

How can someone, who is informed about opportunities to express their opinion during agency open comment periods, be a victim? Federal agencies, by law, must hold public hearings on new regulations before implementing those rules. That is the essence of “for the people, by the people.” The people get to weigh in before any regulation is published or enforced. The Western Colorado Congress of Mesa County gives people the tools they need in order to be informed on issues before commenting on them. It empowers people rather than victimizing them.

Kevin King, you should have actually read the Udall article before you assumed that fracking is safe. What Udall said is that it is safe IF wells are encased from top to bottom. An industry CEO is featured in a commercial (currently running every news cycle) stating that their wells are safe because they enclose them from top to bottom in steel and cement and the production zone is deep underground, with layers of impermeable rock between the zone and surface water. That particular company MAY do that on all wells. I know for a fact that Colorado’s regulations only require only a portion of a well to be fully encased. I learned that from a Williams Petroleum representative when I toured some of their rigs and other facilities near Rifle.  It is expensive to encase a well top to bottom in cement and steel. With profit the prime motivator for all business, as it should be, how likely is it that exploration companies enclose wells top to bottom in Colorado when it is not required that they do so? The largest local company doesn’t. They told me so.

I want clean water. I don’t want to be a victim. I want regulations on how wells are completed along the Colorado River. I want a river teeming with fish, nourishing local foods and wildlife, and clean enough to swim or boat in. Kevin, your ignorance makes you the victim, not me.

Along the same lines of willful ignorance and victimhood, the Board of School District 51 was presented with the results of a survey of local residents. Because of all of the recent cuts to budgets, the school district is toying with the idea of asking for a mill levy override so that they could hire more teachers, or more accurately hire some of the teachers they’ve had to eliminate. A majority (52%) of the respondents said they would support a mill levy override. But the consulting company concluded that such a bill would not pass in Happy Valley, primarily because of local economic concerns. Their opinion was that unless 58% of the population would support such an issue when first presented with the idea, it would not pass after idiots like Kevin King spewed forth their uninformed bile.

In the Wild West the first sign of civilization was when five or six families got together to bring a school teacher to their emerging community. They valued education, prioritized education, and paid for it even as they were barely eking out a living. What happened to that frontier spirit? When did we become so afraid of our own ability to create a civilization out of the wilderness? When did we decide to forgo investment in the future of our kids?

The Democrats of Mesa County recently sponsored a gun safety class for local school kids. In order to get a gun safety card, the kids have to pass a written test. A little less than one fourth of those kids would not have passed the test if someone did not read the test questions to them. They were unable to read the questions for themselves. That’s the definition of victim, Kevin, a kid who is functionally illiterate because our schools are failing them, and parents like you are unwilling to invest in anything that informs kids or citizens.

Homework

Results of School District 51 Survey

Western Colorado Congress of Mesa County

Links to Federal and State Drilling Regulations
 
 
Locally, whenever oil and gas regulations are discussed it looks like a professional wrestling match. In one corner are the environmentalists and in the other corner are the industry plus the chamber of commerce plus the local elected officials. Since leaders of the chamber and local county commissioners have personal investments in the oil and gas industry, they are protecting their own pocketbooks, not representing what is best for the environment. Against a foe with every advantage of money, position power, and media control, the environmentalists are the guys getting thrown out of the ring and hit over the head with folding chairs.

When drilling slowed down in Mesa County, one of the contributing factors was the new play in the Marcellus Shale formation, although you have to know enough to search the internet for information to know anything about that. Local media has kept up the drumbeat of Ritter’s Regulations, Ritter’s Regulations, Ritter’s Regulations.

The wrestling match looks very different half a continent away in Pennsylvania, West Virginia and New York. Without data either side could claim to be right about the impacts of drilling in the Marcellus formation. Facts would be the victim of muscle. Recognizing the lay-out of the ring, “representatives from six federal agencies, three river basin commissions and four states discussed coordinating their efforts to assess the Marcellus resource and the environmental impact of its development.” Range Resources, a Texas company and pioneer in the Marcellus Shale formation met with a researcher and agreed to participate in a study of the impacts of drilling.

Both sides hope to gather enough data to support their positions. Data is being collected a year in advance of any drilling activity. 120 metrics will be monitored both before and for some time after wells have been completed. Then both sides will have a scientific baseline from which to argue their point of view.

Discussion in the editorial community half a continent away is about whether the states will be able to hire enough qualified scientists and engineers to effectively regulate the industry. With continued budget cuts in Colorado, we may not be able to maintain scientific expertise in our regulatory agencies.

Unlike the local media, with its constant chant of Ritter’s Regulations, Ritter’s Regulations, Ritter’s Regulations, the editorial community in the middle of the Marcellus formation is warning former Governor Tom Ridge that he could jeopardize his local reputation with his $900,000 contract advising the natural gas industry. In Pennsylvania the chant could be Ridge’s Folly, Ridge’s Folly, Ridge’s Folly.

Homework:

Marcellus Shale Environmental Study

Need for Top Notch Engineers

Former Governor Ridge
 
 
Today an editorial in the Sentinel issued a challenge to campaigns.  So, by all means, as campaigns heat up, let’s demand that candidates tell us what they think should be done with the rules. But let’s not forget that just a few years ago, many Coloradans were demanding stricter regulations because they had witnessed first-hand what could occur when there weren’t adequate protections.”

Fair enough. I haven’t read all of the existing rules, nor researched enough to give you my complete opinion yet. But I will tell you that my campaign will always be guided by a value proposition that says that we should leave the environment cleaner than when we found it; that we should think about how our decisions will protect the vulnerable; that the jobs programs we support should create sustainable jobs as opposed to those jobs that come during boom times and disappear during bust times; that our focus should always be on how we can educate our kids and prepare them to be critical thinkers because they are our future.

The local hype makes it sound like all drilling in Colorado stopped, yet in terms of actual rigs working; Colorado is second only to New Mexico. Maybe going slow is better than drilling every possible well site yesterday. Maybe if our boom and bust cycles were less dramatic we wouldn’t see house values decrease and rental vacancies and foreclosures increase every time the oil and gas industry decides it is not economically feasible to drill every possible site in our backyard.

I was an oil and gas lender in Denver during the last boom and bust cycle. Some of the current political leaders aren’t old enough to remember that this has been happening in Grand Junction since the boom and bust cycle of the uranium industry--maybe longer. We can do better. One way to do better is to create a sensible road map for the development of our natural resources that minimizes boom and bust cycles.